My perception of negan was way off as seems to be a lot of comic book fans. Spoilers ahead for the walking dead season 10 the walking dead s whisperers are even scarier and more effective on tv than they are in the comic books. Since negan has yet to be shown on the walking dead tv show, the source of comparison will have to come from the comic book series. Comic book negan was something of a revelation for what villains could be like, and robert kirkman made him brash and brazen and completely unhinged in a terrifyinglyhinged sort of way. Youll find a lot of people here who hate negan because the way he is presented on screen isnt how they viewed him in the comics. Jun 26, 2017 negan is coming to the walking deadand hes bringing allout war with him the very sound of the iconic comic book villains name, uttered onscreen for the first time in a postfinale. How the walking dead changed up negan and alphas comic story.
The walking dead ii negan show vs the comics youtube. Despite the divergent storylines in other parts of the episode, the majority of negan and carls arc in sing me a. In robert kirkmans original the walking dead story, the whisperers arrive in the wake of the landmark all out war arc against negan and the saviors. Eugene porter is a main character first encountered in issue 53 of image comics the walking dead. The walking dead showrunner talks villain negan and season 6. Walking dead makes the whisperers scarier than the comics.
Is the walking dead, the tv show better than the comics. Negans backstory in the walking dead comics popsugar. Rick vs negan finale comparison tv show vs comic book the. Comics comparison and analysis last updated by erik norris on nov 22, 2010 03. The walking dead cast compared to comicbook characters insider. This inspires one of negan s most iconic comic book deliveries, in which he speaks to his wifes death. He truly is straight from the pages to the screen an exact replica. Are you an avid watcher of the walking dead who thought both the comics and tv series were the same. Similarities and differences between comic and season premiere. He is the leader of a group of survivors in the sanctuary, called the saviors, a group that oppresses other survivor communities and forces them to pay tribute to him. See more ideas about the walking dead, walking dead comics and twd comics.
Jeffrey dean morgans negan is a villain tv audiences are going to love to loathe. Or that negan looks totally different as a comic book character. Spoilers for both the show and comic book series follow. From batswinging big bad to redemption seeking antihero, once savior leader negan is successfully rehabilitated by rick grimes in robert kirkmans walking dead comic books a path his. Heres how the battle between rick and negan ends on paper. Everyones mileage will vary on some of these, and others will wonder. Season 10 episode 1 compared to robert kirkmans comics below. Would the walking dead show follow the comic book path on this pivotal death, or would it remix the moment as its done so. I still say they need to use her as bait when they need a diversion. There have been many tragic deaths on the walking dead tv show but it pales in comparison to the losses in the comic books.
Oct 24, 2016 the walking dead finally let negan deliver his killer blow in the season 7 premiere. Ricks son carl is played by chandler riggs who grew up on the show. Walking dead season 8 needs to ditch comics after negan. Such was the case in sundays penultimate episode of. Last nights walking dead frustrated comic book fans in more ways than one. Negan in the walking dead tv show compared to the comics. The walking dead showrunner talks comic villain negan and. Most prominently, the episode ended without a real. Apr 16, 2017 while the whole season has been a gradual introduction to his world, we do know how the rest of negan s storyline plays out in the comic book series.
Apr 10, 2016 the walking dead ii negan show vs the comics aj comerate. Nov 16, 2017 long before the walking dead became one of the biggest shows on television, it was a popular comic book series. Or are you one of the many wringing their hands in despair because you find the two completely different. Spoilers ahead for the walking dead season 10 the walking deads whisperers are even scarier and more effective on tv than they are in the comic books. Robert kirkman is an american comic book writer best known for his work on the walking dead, invincible for image comics, as well as ultimate xmen and marvel zombies for marvel.
Negan is a fictional character in the comic book series the walking dead and in the television series of the same name. Apr 04, 2016 15 more big differences between the walking dead tv show and comics. He is at first an awkward, sloppy and depressed, supposed government scientist who knows how the apocalypse started and how it can be cured. This post discusses characters and events from the walking dead comic that may also appear. And in the years since, the two have become a pop culture juggernaut with an active. Negan is my favorite character in the walking dead comic books and tv adaptation, obviously i had read the comic this is a special publication of the walking dead, not part of the regular run, therefore, its only avalaible at this moment in this very hardcover publication. If the walking dead stays true to the comic book script, then negan has nothing to worry about right now, and father gabriel wont have to face his own demise until much further down the line. Many walking dead fans have begun to rely on ricks authority as. Sep 05, 2017 the walking dead 7x07 comic book comparison. The walking dead returned to negans home base, the sanctuary, in season sevens seventh episode, sing me a song. The walking dead 7x07 comic book comparison the walking dead appears to be at its best when it closely mirrors robert kirkmans source material. By now, youve probably heard that negan s violent introduction to the walking dead s core characters was eerily similar to the comic book s plot.
As the walking dead heads into season 10, the tv series is arguably more. This was a heck of a scene pulled off by the walking dead showrunners. Find all the books, read about the author, and more. Tbh, even though the exact dialog from the comic would not fit here due to the context pre war vs. The walking dead upcoming shows are a mystery, and its only through the plot synopsis from the shows and tv promos where viewers can figure out what the saviors are up to. It focuses on rick grimes, a kentucky deputy who is shot in the line of duty and awakens from a coma in a zombie apocalypse that has. The new installment honed in on one of the comic books most fascinating onpage.
The walking dead creator robert kirkman discusses season 4 and whether theres any thoughts of introducing charismatic bad guy negan on the amc show earlier than where he. Could the walking dead introduce negan sooner than. The walking dead is an american postapocalyptic comic book series created by writer robert kirkman and artist tony moore who was the artist on the first 6 issues and cover artist for the first 24 with art on the remainder of the series by charlie adlard. There is little on negans backstory, except that he worked as a usedcar salesman and enjoyed playing billiards and pingpong before the walkers ruled the earth. The walking dead cast compared to comicbook characters.
Essentially, if amcs the walking dead continues following its comic book source religiously, season 8 will see negan taken prisoner, and the. Negan is coming to the walking deadand hes bringing allout war with him the very sound of the iconic comic book villains name, uttered onscreen for the first time in a postfinale. Differences between the walking dead comics and the show. Eugene was traveling with abraham and rosita who protected him with their lives, until stumbling across ricks group and revealing that his mission is a lie. The walking dead s characters and storylines may play out quite differently on screen as opposed to in ink but the creator of the comic, robert kirkman, and the maker of twd tv series. Mar 09, 2016 since negan has yet to be shown on the walking dead tv show, the source of comparison will have to come from the comic book series. The walking dead s negan has been one of the most talked about characters on television, in part because of how he talks. Ahead of the midseason premiere, we look at the series most evil antagonist to date. The walking dead is back, and so are our comic vs show posts. His huge army and stockpile of weapons give him an edge over the. Negan pulls a carol and cancer strikes a king on the walking. They are grouped by families or groups of survivors and roughly in order of first appearance. The new installment honed in on one of the comic book s most fascinating onpage.
Walking dead comics walking dead comic book fear the walking dead power walking walking dead season the. The walking dead ii negan show vs the comics aj comerate. For brandon, the outcome in this weeks the walking dead, what. Honestly no you can read this to know his origin but it wont change anything from the comic book. Jan 17, 2018 but did you know that rick loses a hand in the graphic novel. It doesnt really tie into any of the stories other than the. The walking dead tv series and comicbook spoilers will be found below. There is little on negans backstory, except that he worked as a usedcar salesman and enjoyed playing.
While the show follows most major plot points form the comic about 4 years ago, mind you, the characters from both versions have deviated so much from the original sources, and both the comics and th. Check out more shocking differences between the walking dead tv show and comic. How the walking dead changed up negan and alphas comic. How the walking dead changed up negan and alphas comic story in the midseason premiere. While the whole season has been a gradual introduction to his world, we do know how the rest of negans storyline plays out in the comicbook series. In issue 149 of the comics, negan does the same with rick, whos. Nov 05, 2016 negans visit to alexandria, a comic comparison. See more ideas about walking dead comics, the walking dead and walking. It stuck true to the comics but put sasha into hollys place. The comic book version tells a tale of their visit to alexandria and rick is made to hold onto lucille the barb wired bat, according to an overview by the hollywood. Jul 31, 2015 the walking dead showrunner talks villain negan and season 6. Below, lets look at how negan and alphas partnership, as it were, compared and contrasted to how robert kirkman laid things out in the walking dead comic book. For comic book fans of the walking dead, the arrival of the saviors meant, ultimately, the death of a much loved character. Lori rejects shane in a walking dead comic book page.
For brandon, the outcome in this weeks the walking dead, what it always is, is the same as in the comics. Most prominently, the episode ended without a real conclusion. In the written iteration, found in the heres negan portion of the walking dead comics, we learn that negans facebashing bat is named lucille as a tribute to his fallen wife, whod stuck with. Daryl is an original character to the walking dead show. The character was first made famous by robert kirkmans the walking dead. A character with an unknown status was alive when last seen, but was injured, lost, or unsecured since. Negan pulls a carol and cancer strikes a king on the. Negan kills rapist david death comparison the walking. Heres how the cast of the walking dead looks compared to their comicbook counterparts. In one of the most iconic scenes in image comics and skybounds the walking dead comic book series, negan and some of the saviors catch up to a vehicle with survivors from alexandria inside.
The calm before contained more comic comparisons than almost any other. Rick vs negan in the finale of the walking dead season 8 that was a sight to behold. Negan pronounced neegan is a main character and a former antagonist first encountered in issue 100 of image comics the walking dead as well as the protagonist of heres negan. The following is a complete pictorial list of the characters in image comics. Despite the divergent storylines in other parts of the episode, the majority of. Oct 06, 2019 below, weve rounded up the 20 biggest differences between the walking dead tv show and robert kirkmans comic book series. The 20 biggest differences between amcs the walking dead and. The walking dead season 9 episode 15 contained the most comic. Dec 05, 2016 the walking dead returned to negan s home base, the sanctuary, in season sevens seventh episode, sing me a song. Now, rick has brought together three communities alexandria, the hilltop, and the kingdom in the war against negan.
The comic book version tells a tale of their visit to alexandria and rick is made to hold onto lucille the barb wired. Apr 04, 2016 negan in the walking dead tv show compared to the comics. Eugene porter comic series walking dead wiki fandom. The walking dead showrunner talks comic villain negan. Lori rejects shane in a walking dead comic book page shane hasnt quite come to grips with the ricktator being back on the scene. We were all traumatized by the walking dead s season 7 premiere. Click on the arrow to progress through and see how the tv shows major kills compare to glenns in the comics. Before negan appears in the comics, rick has had his life, but not his worldview, threatened. Alphas gang represent a very different threat, more silent and unnerving than the. We havent met negan yet on the walking dead season but heres a list of everyone hes killed so far in the twd comics. Negan is one of the biggest threats rick and his people have faced on the walking dead, and hell be a difficult one to defeat. Oct 10, 2017 if youre a fan of the walking dead, but you didnt want to buy a monthly magazine publication to read small chunks of negan s history spread out over the course of a year, then heres negan. In the walking dead comic book, rick grimes had to learn for himself how the. Spoilers tv negan vs comic negan when talking to dave.
846 1436 1197 952 1293 1077 591 386 1411 1382 1111 233 132 1411 1184 566 317 1341 200 1361 1317 865 622 381 1120 276 1301 670 1015 413 689